It's been an emotional evening. It's the eve of the EU Referendum, which has unleashed forces of misogyny and xenophobia that have ended in murder. I fully support giving the people the right to decide, but turning over this particular stone has had consequences I (naively) didn't predict. There have also been some particularly awful news stories that have had an impact on me - the murder of children in Syria and right here in the UK. Tonight I've been reading the experiences of women having the most terrible experiences which made me so full of anger and sadness (and confirmed all my feelings about being 100% pro-choice).
And all this sturm und drang has coincided with the beginning of digging season: my social media feeds are flooded with friends returning to the most beautiful Tuscan village where, although bad things certainly happened when I was there, my memory provides a warped vision of golden summers filled with friends and the joy of science and discovery. My friend Theresa just wrote the most lovely piece on the FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out) caused by not being there.
I wonder if the real reason I grieve for not spending 8 weeks digging in Italy this summer is not the high of excavation, or the high jinks of celebrations/commisserations. I don't think it's the food, wine or views that I'm really missing. I think it's the entirely false impression that in that enchanted place, in this safe space, there are no problems that our wonderful excavation director can't work out, and that can't be forgotten with a little grappa, a hug and a late night conversation with a good friend.
I think that's a testament to the site and its running, and I'm sure that experience was not universal: I certainly saw people battle with homesickness, personal issues, relationships and grief. Nostalgia is a false friend. But those summers were before I really saw Etruscan archaeology with the gloves off at a hostile, sexist conference, before I lost a pregnancy and came damn near losing another one, back when I had a funded PhD position and an engagement ring and was sure that the world would be a feast of opportunities and joys.
Those experiences are the reason it doesn't feel the same when I go back, the reason the FOMO bites me personally so hard.
As with everything in archaeology, the major issue is I can't go back in time.
Beautiful things from past and present, the objects and thoughts that make up the life of an archaeologist
Showing posts with label Poggio Civitate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Poggio Civitate. Show all posts
Wednesday, 22 June 2016
Tuesday, 27 August 2013
Bone: Digging Up Stuff
Thank you all so much for your lovely words (mostly not in blog comments but elsewhere) and for all the support that flowed in after last week's post about starting my new job. Another week has gone by and I'm still delighted- it is Bank Holiday Monday and I can't help wishing (in a sneaky little geeky way) that I'm at work! What a loser! Anyway, as it is a day off, I can blog- and I thought as it's time for a "Bones" post that I'd blog about the things I found this summer that actually connect up to people in the past. Things that you too can look at online, via the Poggio Civitate Excavation Database- we're proud to be fully open access (when the server is working, at least). Twelve artefacts that my team found in my trench made it into the cataloguing system that we use for artefacts that have a meaningful interpretative role to play. Of course, everything we find is recorded and in many cases drawn in our trench books- before being counted and recorded at the close of the book. Don't worry- all the information is safely stored in the magazzino, even to the weight of single pieces of slag.
I'm sorry that I can't
tell you more about the features in the trench- I don't want to
pre-empt the peer-reviewed publication and presentation. But I
thought I'd write up those twelve things, including a link to them
all- pulling together what they might mean for the site, as well as
how they were recovered. I often joke around with colleagues
about "interpretation at the trowel's edge." This series of
posts, I suppose, is exactly that- a biographical account of the
discovery of these fascinating yet often mundane objects.
The first of my twelve had the honour of being
labelled as PC20130001. It was found when I wasn't even in the
trench, as I had gone back to England to have the interview for my
new job! Our fab site director Kate stepped in to supervise for me,
so this is really a find for her! My trench assistant John "Georgia"
Duggan (who will have his own trench next year hopefully as he is a
fantastic excavator and a great prospect for the future!) was working
on the removal of a large stump, when out popped this particular
find, a shining lump of metal. Everyone (I imagine) got excited, as
there were little nubs of gilt on this object, which made it look
really enticing. Unfortunately, it's not Etruscan. It's probably
post-medieval. It's a gorgeous bronze pendant, which would have been
covered in gilding, and it's moulded to show the figure of San
Domenico on one side, identified by an inscription, and a woman and
child (presumably the Virgin) on the other. It's a find that made me
sad when I saw it after I got back- and not just because I missed
finding it. I imagine a person losing that pendant, and feeling sad
and full of regrets- and I know that's just splashing emotions
inappropriately all over the past, but that's my honest and
instinctive reaction. More seriously, the pendant confirms what we
suspected- the area in which the trench was located, Civitate A, was
clearly still being traversed by people in the centuries after Poggio
Civitate was abandoned- over a thousand years later, someone came
through, perhaps a shepherd or traveller, and lost this pendant.
The next find (PC20130108) is Etruscan, or at
least, I assume it was. And unlike the previous find, this one I
found myself. I was excavating with my trowel in the eastern end of
my trench, working in a locus (the locus system defines the
contextual layers of soil in the order that we remove them, which
SHOULD be the reverse order in which they were deposited) that was
producing relatively large amounts of bone and pottery. I spotted
this weird shape with my trowel- a circle, with a dirty cream edge
smeared with dark earth. I rubbed the object very gently with my
fingers, and pressed in the centre where the mud was- to find that it
fell away. A super careful probe with my trowel point, and it was
clear that this was a nicely hollowed out piece of worked bone,
making a perfect little oval. I pretend that it doesn't matter who
finds things, as we're all part of a team- but I was pretty chuffed
to have this gorgeous little object turn up. The layer that this
piece of worked bone was found in was full of Etruscan material- the
area was clearly pretty busy in antiquity! Yet this little fragment
proved that larger objects incorporating worked bone were either
being made or used in the vicinity.
The third find is again an industrial one
(PC20130112). It looked bloody ugly as it came up- and as we found
quite a few examples of these, I can't remember who actually found
this one. Sorry! It was probably one of the great students we had on
site this year- sharp eyed and sharp brained. One of them probably
thought that this was a piece of pottery at first- a heavy, lumpy
piece of coarseware. Then they turned it over, and found a
weird covering spread all over the inner face- a little bit shiny
where not covered in dirt. The weird covering was actually molten
metal- this pot was used in the process of creating iron artefacts-
the find was a crucible fragment. So, not only do we have evidence
for the presence of worked bone and possibly worked bone production,
we also have evidence for metalworking in the vicinity of Civitate A.
Someone, somewhere, during the Etruscan inhabitation of the site, was
making iron implements.
The final find for this "Bones" post
(PC20130136) is a little bit more exciting- and I remember the
student who found it (I'm so sorry person who found the crucible
fragment!!) as there were not many objects like this found in my
trench this summer. Margot, a student from Mount Holyoke College, had
quite a lot of excavation experience, and had even worked underwater!
It was most likely the green sheen of bronze that first caught her
eye- everyone on site knows that the colour hints at something
special. Carefully using her trowel to free the delicate object from
the soil, she called me over. It was pretty clear at first glance
what Margot had found- a fragment of a fibula, or brooch, made of
bronze. The coiled end and part of the pin were preserved, but the
arch and catch were missing. We didn't find any sign of any other
pieces of the fibula this year, even in slightly lower loci. So, I
suspect that this object was already broken when it was deposited-
thrown away, chucked out. Maybe it was too small to bother melting
back down, maybe it broke while being worn and the piece was never
recovered by the owner. But an Etruscan person was wearing that
fibula at some point in the past, while they were living at Poggio
Civitate. At least one person in this area of the site had access to
a plain, but still quite classy, decorative pin for their clothes.
So, there you are- my first four finds. I've
linked in the find numbers, so you should be able to click on the
"PC" numbers here and see the proper write up by our
amazing cataloguer, Theresa. There aren't professional photographs
yet- but there will be this time next year. Please enjoy browsing
around for what other people found, too. Each find has a little
biography, a story like the ones I've described here. The reactions
of excavators are always fascinating to me- I would love to find some
way of incorporating them into full publications, giving the people
who do the digging a voice! How would you feel about seeing that for
real? Do you think the internet provides an opportunity to open up
archaeological interpretative methodologies? Or is recording instant
reactions and assumptions a dangerous business, undermining the wider
message published by an excavation director? I'm all for embracing
subjectivity- but how far do we go? Let me know if you have any
thoughts, or any discovery stories of your own.
Friday, 9 August 2013
Pots: Digging Everyday
Summer is i'going out- the excavation season is over, I am about to print out the boarding pass for my flight home. There is still a month (maybe) of sunshine and warmth left, but I will be gleaning it from an English sun, rather than a radiant Italian sole. Ironically, the former has apparently been far more reliable than the latter for everyone in the UK. By contrast, here in Tuscany there have been storms aplenty. The storms haven't kept me from updating this blog- that's my own fault. So, for my first post back, I thought I would blog about what it is to work on an archaeological dig- the pottery side of this oh-so-glam profession. Scruffy and messy, broken and worn- that's the state of me after six weeks of digging, just like any of the scrunched pieces of ceramic mess I've hauled out of the ground. But unlike them, I'm pretty bloody satisfied. We. Found. Stuff. I have to be a tease, until that "stuff" is published. What I can tell you, however, is that it was a damn good season. And this is the story of one day of it.
A usual digging day starts at 6am. That's if, like me, you aren't big on breakfast and can walk quickly. Other people are up far earlier, not least the fabulous cooks we had this year, who have been up for an hour by the time my phone squawks in my ear. Time to get dressed- the scruffification (ahem) process begins. Try not to sniff the clothes as you put them on, unless it's a rare treat of fresh ones. Sports bra first. An old t-shirt, sleeves cut off and collar ravaged by kitchen scissors next. Then the oldest denim shorts I own, that have been coming with me to this place for four years and doing sterling service at home, in other places where nobody can see them who will be horrified by their grottiness. Roll down to the kitchen, fill up my water bottles- 4l on board, and a hunk of bread and Nutella in each hand and I'm out and off down the road.
The walk to site, and the quiet time alone (ish) by my trench that is the reward of doing the walk at top speed, are perhaps my favourite parts of the day. The walk is powered by my iPod, and I try and think of nothing but how the air feels and how long I can make my strides before I feel like a total idiot. The hill looms above me, but once the climb begins I am a part of it. Well, sort of. It tries to throw you off with washed out trails, and brambles lie in wait for the unwary or distracted. To the trenches, yawning open. In the early days of digging the earth looks sullen and brown, full of small stones and roots, with tree stumps sprawling in what should be a neat, flat surface. I think about what I want to do to that earth. I do not think about what I might find- or, to be more honest, I try not to.
Students arrive at 7, and we set to work. The methodology is devastatingly simple- pick, scrape, sort, sieve, dump, repeat. The large pick is abandoned after the first few layers of soil, loci, are removed, and work continues with trowels alone for the latter half of the season. The action of the trowel is deceptive. "Scrape with your whole arm," I prate at the students. "Don't use your wrist." It's a surefire way of catching blisters. Equally important is to use the trowel like your hand- hold it like a pen, it's an extension of you. Don't shove it, point with it. It's often better to use the trowel upside down, twisting and flicking the dirt rather than pushing and flailing at it. This is surprisingly hard to explain over the internet.
The trowel should be the first point at which you spot the past. The hand sort is the second check, the sieve the third. You can always repeat the last two, if you're worried you missed something. A paranoid flash of green- was that bronze, or just a leaf? The first two weeks (and more) of any season resound to the nervous questions "is this a rock?" "is this something?" Always better to ask than to assume negatively. A rock is a rock is a rock- but what if it's polished, worked or flaked? Even a rock has a story to tell. The bulk finds squat in their boxes, which are more confidently filled with each passing day. The special finds (anything not undecorated pottery or unworked bone fragments) have their positions and elevations recorded in the trench book, before being drawn into it.
The trench book is my prrrrecious. The pages are how I will be judged as an excavator- you can see me all over it, you can see how tired my hands are by the end of the day, when the standard of drawing, which is always as high as I can make it, begins to wobble. Each precious layer of soil is recorded, every change and variation. Each move of a pick, each scrape of a trowel- it's all in there. Features and finds are drawn, stippled to show light and shade and pattern. The rhythm of digging gets broken by these moments of solitary contemplation- how do I accurately and quickly give the impression of that exact stamped decoration? How to draw a squodged up piece of slag? When it's done, I'm back in the trench.
Lunch comes at 12:00. We hide in the shade for a precous half hour, scarfing down bread, crisps and water. The accompaniments vary, but those are constants- carbs, salt and fluid. Peanut butter and jam on Fridays, sometimes. Cold meats, leftovers from dinner, cheese and eggs. Vegetables, fruit. The sandwich combinations make the mind boggle. We don't care- we're hungry and it tastes fantastic. When the food is gone, the mind goes back to the things in the ground, and after a few short minutes the body does too.
The day ends at 3:30. By ten minutes before, I like to be counting up the bulk finds- locus by locus, carefully recording what was found where. Elevations for the end of the day are taken- how far did we go down? This season, not far. In previous years, metres, though not in a day. Finds, bulk and special, all go to the magazzino- store and conservation studio, to be handed over to cataloguer and conservators for their scrutiny. If you've closed a locus, final pottery and bone counts can be done for it. The trench book must be typed up, to be included on the website
That's the end of the excavation day. And guess what, you're bloody knackered.
Tuesday, 15 January 2013
Bone: Dead Babies and Poggio Civitate
In the summer of 2010, osteoarchaeologist Sarah Kansa was making a detailed examination of hundreds of bags of mixed animal bone, the result of many years of excavation at Poggio Civitate. This site, excavated since 1966, is one of the most significant non-funerary sites in Etruscan archaeology, most famous for the stunning architectural terracottas used to decorate its central complex. It sounds like the start of a novel, or an action/ horror film, as while Sarah was working through the bone remains, she made a discovery- a tiny fragment of human bone which would become the centre of what, to an Etruscan archaeologist, has become a media storm. In typical fashion, I had left Poggio Civitate 2 days before Sarah made her discovery- heading home from excavation a week early to get married. When I returned last summer, one of the first things I did on my first lab day was nonchalantly wander over to Sarah's workspace to look at the group of tiny bones, which Sarah had identified as those of an infant or infants. Their fragility invoked in me a completely unprofessional ethnocentric response connected to human tragedies in the present for me- the loss of a child and the emotions involved. At the time that I first saw the remains, my cousin (and friend) was 8 months pregnant- imagining her and her partner's response, and that of our family, to that precious life ending soon after birth was horrific and disturbing.*
View of Poggio Civitate looking beautiful on a summer's day.
The same reaction which I instinctively felt on seeing the remains is what lies at the heart of what happened when the site director, Dr Anthony Tuck presented the discovery at the American Institute of Archaeology Annual Meeting a week and a half ago. The context of the find, excavated from the Orientalising period workshop building (more information about the workshop in this article by Tuck and Nielson, published in 2001, here ), alongside animal bones and debris, led Tuck to suggest that, possibly, this infant was disposed of without a formalised burial. He went on to raise questions about the status of infants in Etruria, asking whether it could have been possible for stillborn or neonatal infants to be regarded as non-persons at this period. ** The potential for mass exploitation of the emotional reactions I experienced when seeing the remains was picked up by media sources, recognising the potential for a good story- originally by NBC Science , then by Live Science and then by the Daily Mail. The latter's coverage was particularly rotten, even by their standards- describing the site as Roman rather than Etruscan and filled with sensationalist overexcitement and righteous outrage at the barbarism of the past, both features which, while present in the previous articles, were at least slightly understated. ***
The central problem with the coverage, as astutely pointed out by Dr Kristina Killgrove, was the cultural Darwinism inherent in these posts- we in the present treat our infants well, so we can be nicely horrified by past cultures, and vilify and judge their decisions and choices. Yet, at the same time as the Poggio Civitate infant remains were being used as a bolster to our present superiority, a story was breaking in the UK that demonstrated the continuity of practice in the disposal of infant remains as non-persons. This story from Scotland outlined the facts that a crematorium in Edinburgh had been routinely misleading parents about the cremated remains of their children. The Mortonhall Crematorium told parents that no remains would be extant after cremation for them to scatter, as infants are too small to produce ashes for secondary burial. What happened was that ashes were produced, and then buried together in a mass grave over a period of 45 years. Although the placement of the grave was in a "Garden of Rememberance," the remains of neonates were treated distinctly differently from those of adults, and denied individual identity in death. The Mortonhall scandal is not alone: this article by Lynn Morgan outlines another issue of infant status in the modern world- the disposal of foetal remains as medical waste and curation as biological specimens, while there have been two cases of babies found in association with rubbish this year- one still alive after a 50ft fall down a rubbish chute and one found dead at a rubbish dump in Scunthorpe. Whether by distressed and unprepared parents or uncaring authorities, infants are still being treated in a different fashion to adult human remains in the modern world- and this is just in the UK alone! While it is great to see a site you work at in the international news, it would be even better if that news coverage was tempered by sensitivity to the otherness of the past and honesty about practices in the present.
** I don't want to get into the interpretative debate about the context of the bones in detail- it would take this post away from a point about present-centrism, and I'm neither an osteologist nor a forensic taphonomist. Tuck's original presentation presented one hypothesis of disposal alongside rubbish, while Killgrove's response (see link above) suggested a secondary disturbance as responsible for the presence of the infant remains in the workshop. I am tempted to think there is room for a third point of view- looking not, as Killgrove did, to the later Roman world, but north to the European Iron Age. JD Hill's "Ritual and rubbish in the Iron Age of Wessex" presents a different way of thinking about deposition- recognising the incorporation of ritual into the disposal of animal remains, seeming rubbish, and humans. A recent article by Adrian Chadwick further develops the nuances of this argument. If the lines between ritual deposition and chucking away rubbish are recognised as blurred and complex, the infant remains from Poggio Civitate can be seen in a different light. The systematic destruction of Poggio Civitate's Archaic complex certainly points to a hyprid form of deposition at a later point in the site's history.
*** There is a debate here to be had about public, open access archaeology and sensationalisation, but that is another can of worms altogether- and one that, in the wake of the tragic death of Aaron Swartz, is also getting a lot of attention at the moment. Suffice to say, the public deserve better than incorrect, sloppy archaeological journalism as exemplified by the Mail. I know plenty of archaeologists who would be more than happy to provide such assistance as needed!
References (in addition to articles linked to above)
Chadwick, A. M. (2012), Routine Magic, Mundane Ritual. Towards a Unified Notion of Depositional Practice. Oxford Journal of Archaeology,
31: 283–315.
Hill, J. D. (1995). Ritual and rubbish in the Iron Age of Wessex. A study on the formation of a specific archaeological record. Tempus, Oxford.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
